回复:27 阅读:6392
制品公司涉及的臨床宫颈癌普查试验在印度-有夸大HPV检测和贬低细胞学检测的倾向,误导读者

cqzhao 离线

帖子:5518
粉蓝豆:1071
经验:5755
注册时间:2008-09-29
加关注  |  发消息
楼主 发表于 2009-07-17 19:07|举报|关注(0)
浏览排序[ 顺序 逆序 楼主 支持 精彩 ]  快捷回复

The paper HPV screening for cervical cancer in rural India published in N Engl J Med.(one of the most important journal of medicine in the world) 2009 Apr 2;360(14):1385-94.

The conclusion of the paper: In a low resource setting, a single round of HPV testing was associated with a significant reduction in the numbers of advanced cancers or deaths from cervical cancer.Furthermore, the study abstract asserted, "No significant reductions in the numbers of associated deaths were observed in the cytology testing group or in the VIA group, as compared with the control group".

 

In other words, this clinical trial in India demostrate HPV testing can reduce the rate of cervical cancer and its related death, but Pap cytology and VIA have no reduction of cervical cancer related death, same as no any test group (control).

The authors manupulated the statistical numbers and made the results they hope to have.

Why? Industry-company involved the clinical trials. Interests are what people are looking for.

 

I pasted the original abstract here and also Dr. Austin and I wrote the editorial commentary.

标签:
0
添加参考诊断
×参考诊断
  
回复:27 阅读:6392
【免责声明】讨论内容仅作学术交流之用,不作为诊疗依据,由此而引起的法律问题作者及本站不承担任何责任。
快速回复
进入高级回复
您最多可输入10000个汉字,按 "Ctrl" + "Enter" 直接发送
搜索回复/乘电梯 ×
按内容
按会员
乘电梯
合作伙伴
友情链接